A Star Is Born (1954) | Great Movies

Tagline: The applause of the world — and then this!

A Star is Born is the superb 1954 musical, acclaimed by many as the greatest Hollywood musical ever made. Judy Garland’s intense performance as the main character, probably the finest of her entire career, illuminates the film based upon Moss Hart’s screenplay. It is a remake of William Wellman’s original 1937 film by the same name that starred Janet Gaynor. The third version was a poorly made A Star is Born (1976) with Barbra Streisand as a pop singer named Esther Hoffman and Kris Kristofferson as John Norman Howard – a rock star.

The film’s director, George Cukor, had also directed the film What Price Hollywood? (1932) that is considered the source of all three film versions. Cukor ironically commented upon Hollywood and how it only cared for its own by strategically positioning three official Hollywood ceremonies at the beginning, middle, and end of the film. Each one chronicled the downfall of a talented, but alcoholic Hollywood movie star (James Mason). [Actors who rejected the role included Humphrey Bogart, Cary Grant (who accepted but then declined), Gary Cooper, Marlon Brando, and Montgomery Clift.]

The emotionally-intense film also hinted at the real-life troubles and problems (five marriages) in the career of its female star – a victim of the Hollywood studio system – during the film’s making. Garland’s realistic performance reflected the upheavals in her own personal life that led to her death from a drug overdose – and ironically, this film’s co-star James Mason delivered her funeral’s eulogy in New York in 1969. Predicted to win the Best Actress Oscar, Garland was devastated by the loss to Grace Kelly in an lesser role in The Country Girl.